Dallas Sports Journal

Your Teams. Your Journal.

Search our reporting

Dallas Cowboys

‘Not Going To Teach’: Andrew Hawkins Says Mike Pettine Play-Calling Switch Can’t Fix Dallas Cowboys’ Tackling

Andrew Hawkins, who played for Mike Pettine in Cleveland, said the Dallas Cowboys’ defensive play-calling switch can’t cure tackling, pursuit, and effort problems.

Share This StoryEmail Story
Former Cleveland Browns wide receiver Andrew Hawkins, wearing a No. 16 jersey, raises a guitar overhead before a packed crowd.
File photo: Former Cleveland Browns wide receiver Andrew Hawkins raises a guitar during a pregame ceremony before the Browns’ game against the Cincinnati Bengals at Huntington Bank Field in Cleveland on Sept. 7, 2025. Mandatory Credit: Ken Blaze-Imagn Images via Reuters Connect
In this article

DALLAS — Andrew Hawkins agreed Thursday on ESPN’s Get Up that the Dallas Cowboys had to make a move, but said handing defensive play-calling to Mike Pettine won’t fix their tackling, pursuit, and effort.

Cowboys coach Brian Schottenheimer announced Wednesday that Pettine will take over the defensive calls, while Christian Parker keeps his title as defensive coordinator. Schottenheimer said the decision was made Tuesday morning after a conversation Monday. Pettine was hired five weeks earlier.

The change came after a 46-40 loss to the San Francisco 49ers on Sunday, when Dallas allowed 584 yards, the most the team has ever given up at home. Through 10 games, the Cowboys ranked 32nd in the NFL in yards allowed per game and 30th in points allowed per game.

San Francisco scored three touchdowns of 66 yards or longer in that game, along with a 25-yarder, DSJ reported Wednesday. Hawkins said a head coach in Schottenheimer’s spot had to make this call, citing what he thought were three touchdowns of 65 yards or more in that loss. He drew a line at what a new play-caller can teach.

“The calls that you make defensively are not going to teach your guys to make tackles,” Hawkins said.

He said the calls won’t teach running the alley or effort down the field either, adding that those are their biggest issue.

Andrew Hawkins Vouches For Mike Pettine’s Experience

Hawkins played for the Cleveland Browns in 2014 and 2015, when Pettine was the team’s head coach. ESPN lists Hawkins as a six-year NFL veteran and an analyst on Get Up.

Hawkins called Pettine his former head coach, one with a lot of experience calling plays on defense. He said the Dallas defense also looked the same under previous coordinators Matt Eberflus and Mike Zimmer, both longtime NFL coaches. Hawkins said the organization has other defensive issues to address and that Parker has to do better.

Dallas Cowboys Plan More Tackling Work Before Tennessee Titans Visit

Schottenheimer listed communication, ball security, and tackling as areas that need to improve when he spoke Wednesday. He planned to put the Cowboys back in pads Thursday, with some personnel and playing-time adjustments he did not specify.

Schottenheimer also said he plans for Pettine to call the defense for the rest of the season rather than on a week-to-week basis. Pettine’s focus is on pressuring the quarterback with a player-based approach, while Parker keeps running meetings and walkthroughs in a collaborative game-planning setup.

Kenny Clark, who played for Pettine with the Green Bay Packers from 2018 to 2020, said Wednesday that Dallas isn’t installing an entirely new defense and that no single call will fix things. Clark said the players have to execute. He also credited Pettine with already helping the fronts and pressures.

Players still get the calls from a linebacker on the field, and Parker remains heavily involved in the weekly game plan. The Cowboys (4-6) host the Tennessee Titans at noon CT Sunday at AT&T Stadium.

Join the conversation

Keep comments relevant and respectful. Comments are moderated.